I can't imagine a better hurricane hole, if you are really worried go over the ledge at high tide and all the way in. Friendly and helpful locals too. We were there waiting for Earl, it was not crowded. Had a hurricane party on a Duffy 42 in the afternoon, Earl turned out to be plenty of rain but the wind never got over 20 kts. It is also pretty, I would stop again even if a hurricane wasn't nearby.