Cruising Sailors Forum Archive
I was agreeing with you Tom
In Response To: Surfing 25 knots in reverse, isn't relevent to my point, Mark. 
()
() And providing a practical limit at the same time. I also do not think being forced backwards at a knot or two while against the stops should break anything in the steering system.
BTW, did that rudder come off a 120' catamaran? 
Mark
Messages In This Thread
- Interesting comment by Charles Doane on his blog
- I saw that. The gremlins in that story are inside those rudders.
- I've been surprised by a couple of comments made in follow up to this event...
- I'm not. The experts a thousand miles away always make the most noise.
- You're right, of course - but I was actually thinking of Charlie's subsequent comments/clarifications (grin)
- Ahh. Close reaching vs. fore reaching, 4 kts. vs. 6 kts. 'considerable discrepancies' between captain and crew?
- Don't disagree with your first comment at all...
- Don't forget the simple stuff, 2 rudders folded up on this new boat as it was going through the water.
- Well, by the same token, don't ignore the obvious... (grin)
- I think a new rudder should put up with any force the water applies.
- Doane says the shaft was not bent.
- It probably would have happened anyway
- Surfing 25 knots in reverse, isn't relevent to my point, Mark.
- Don't underestimate the forces...
- I was agreeing with you Tom
- Surfing 25 knots in reverse, isn't relevent to my point, Mark.
- I think a new rudder should put up with any force the water applies.
- Well, by the same token, don't ignore the obvious... (grin)
- Don't forget the simple stuff, 2 rudders folded up on this new boat as it was going through the water.
- Don't disagree with your first comment at all...
- Ahh. Close reaching vs. fore reaching, 4 kts. vs. 6 kts. 'considerable discrepancies' between captain and crew?
- You're right, of course - but I was actually thinking of Charlie's subsequent comments/clarifications (grin)
- Well Jon, as has been pointed out, I'm no engineer
- I'm not. The experts a thousand miles away always make the most noise.
- Here's the cached page
- I saw that. The gremlins in that story are inside those rudders.