You could criticize him for his lack of sailing experience and knowledge, that's obvious(and he admits).

But if in fact, he survived in his situation, don't you think that's pretty admirable? That long with those injuries and damage-that would be a feat! He appears to be a guy who's suffered some trauma and shock in the video.

I think the worst charges I've seen on the web are insinuations he may have staged this. Pretty heavy charges if in fact, the guy is just telling the truth.